FishingTN.com Tennessee's Fishing and Boating Community

FishingTN.com Tennessee's Fishing and Boating Community (http://www.fishingtn.com/index.php)
-   Local Fishing (http://www.fishingtn.com/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Dam Restriction update From Doug Markham (http://www.fishingtn.com/showthread.php?t=6047)

creeksmallie 12-10-2012 10:26 PM

Dam Restriction update From Doug Markham
 
I have learned today that the "public" meeting the Corps intends to hold as it concerns boat restrictions below dams will be to TELL US WHAT THE NEW RESTRICTIONS will be. If it is a public hearing or meeting, I hope we all gather in numbers they have never seen before to tell them that THIS IS OUR STATE. I will keep you posted. Look for Mike Organ to have an article in Thursday's Tennessean.

j19bill 12-10-2012 11:57 PM

So basically their just going to tell us what they are going to do and to hell with what we think ...

I see all fazes of the government are the same.

Sent from my DROID BIONIC using Tapatalk 2

Catch & Release 12-12-2012 02:31 PM

Here is the # to Lamar Alexander's office in Washington:202 224 4944
I believe he is the only one who can stop this. Everyone please give him a call and let them know you thoughts on this issue, because I believe after tomorrow it will be all over but the crying.....

fisher01 12-12-2012 03:13 PM

Here's Lieutenant Colonel James A. DeLapp Commander


Brigadier General Margaret W. Burcham
Commander and Division Engineer
Great Lakes and Ohio River Division

U.S.Army Engineer Division,
Great Lakes & Ohio River Division
ATTN: Public Affairs Office
550 Main Street, Room 10524
Cincinnati, Ohio 45202-3222
(513) 684-3010
http://www.lrd.usace.army.mil/

Time is running out, here is who the Lieutenant Colonel reports to. We need our voices heard.

Mnfishingbum 12-12-2012 03:19 PM

Where and when is this meeting?

Travis C. 12-12-2012 03:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mnfishingbum (Post 27434)
Where and when is this meeting?

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (Dec.11, 2012) - On Dec. 13, 2012, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers will announce its change in operation to comply with existing policy on Restricted Access to Hazardous Waters around Corps Dams. The announcement follows a week that saw productive meetings between the Nashville District Commander, Lt. Col. James DeLapp, and other Corps officials with members of the Tennessee and Kentucky congressional delegations and other key stakeholders.

WHO: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Nashville District

WHAT: Announce its plans to implement Corps policy on Restricted Access to Hazardous Water around Corps Dams

WHEN: Thursday, Dec. 13, 2012 at 1-2 p.m. CST

WHERE: ViaTeleconference

Travis C. 12-12-2012 03:53 PM

Not much time for public input or gathering to show support via telephone for an hour... :cool:

I guess get ready to hear what they decided.

tkwalker 12-12-2012 07:43 PM

Channel 4 news tonight .. <'TK><
 
Did you see the segment on CH 4 tonight at 6:30 (12-12-12) ... May be back on at 10:00 .... <'TK>< :confused:

Alphahawk 12-12-2012 07:47 PM

Yep saw it. I just hope this gets stopped. I am sick to death of "Big Brother".

Regards

Greasy Ham 12-12-2012 10:29 PM

Isn't there something about waterways being public domain or something like that which would not allow this? I mean it's technically a river. Not a lake on private land.
I'm grasping at straws I know.

agelesssone 12-12-2012 11:02 PM

A friend, who is ex-military, says that all this is, is a military person leaving himself a "legacy", making his mark as it were, disregarding the wishes of the constituents of the state of Tennessee because they have no bearing on his actions nor are of any consequence to him, as he is not an elected official and cannot be held to harm for his actions.

Maybe the next commander of the Corps of Engineers can/will retract this moron's actions. We can only hope so because this action of restricting access to the immediate tail waters seems to be a foregone conclusion at this point in time.

I note that the TWRA officers on this page are decrying this action also, but in the next breath, they will be the ones issuing citations to boaters who venture into the "no boating" zone. If they are really serious about not wanting these restrictions, maybe they'll be "too busy" to write citations for these transgressions.....much the same as they don't seem to care to write citations to illegal fishermen below the dams who keep everything that comes ashore in their castnets.

If I have to pay taxes and register and number a canoe just because I put a "TROLLING MOTOR" on it, I'd like to see some enforcement of the laws already on the books concerning the castnetting crowd.

I'm done venting, thank you for reading!

Alphahawk 12-12-2012 11:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by agelesssone (Post 27442)
A friend, who is ex-military, says that all this is, is a military person leaving himself a "legacy", making his mark as it were, disregarding the wishes of the constituents of the state of Tennessee because they have no bearing on his actions nor are of any consequence to him, as he is not an elected official and cannot be held to harm for his actions.

Maybe the next commander of the Corps of Engineers can/will retract this moron's actions. We can only hope so because this action of restricting access to the immediate tail waters seems to be a foregone conclusion at this point in time.

I note that the TWRA officers on this page are decrying this action also, but in the next breath, they will be the ones issuing citations to boaters who venture into the "no boating" zone. If they are really serious about not wanting these restrictions, maybe they'll be "too busy" to write citations for these transgressions.....much the same as they don't seem to care to write citations to illegal fishermen below the dams who keep everything that comes ashore in their castnets.

If I have to pay taxes and register and number a canoe just because I put a "TROLLING MOTOR" on it, I'd like to see some enforcement of the laws already on the books concerning the castnetting crowd.

I'm done venting, thank you for reading!


Having a 7 year career in the Army.....then another 23 years working with a major defense firm and working with and around the Army...you come to learn once a regulation is made it is very hard to overturn. Doug Markham mentioned this also. It does not matter how stupid a regulation is once it is made it is done. My hope is that due to all the publicity that someone above that O5 has told him to drop it. If enough pressure was to be put on his superiors...say the O6's and General ranking officers they could tell him to squash it and I can assure he would....that is if he ever wanted to be promoted to O6. Makes me wonder though is this idea strictly from Lt. Colonel DeLapp...or someone above him. I guess we will find out tomorrow who's idea this is and what it will entail. Then our work will begin if the tailraces are closed to fishing. There is no doubt that we as sportsman will make such a ruckus that it will get somebody's attention much higher than a Lt. Colonel.

Regards

tkwalker 12-13-2012 12:05 AM

Keep Pumping !!! <'TK><
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Alphahawk (Post 27443)
Having a 7 year career in the Army.....then another 23 years working with a major defense firm and working with and around the Army...you come to learn once a regulation is made it is very hard to overturn. Doug Markham mentioned this also. It does not matter how stupid a regulation is once it is made it is done. My hope is that due to all the publicity that someone above that O5 has told him to drop it. If enough pressure was to be put on his superiors...say the O6's and General ranking officers they could tell him to squash it and I can assure he would....that is if he ever wanted to be promoted to O6. Makes me wonder though is this idea strictly from Lt. Colonel DeLapp...or someone above him. I guess we will find out tomorrow who's idea this is and what it will entail. Then our work will begin if the tailraces are closed to fishing. There is no doubt that we as sportsman will make such a ruckus that it will get somebody's attention much higher than a Lt. Colonel.


Regards

Thanks Alpha great post ... Folks I Have kept Doug Markham abreast of FTI post and our support ... Please keep posting and sending protest to our political gaurdians, Some better than others !!! .. I really don't think TWRA will police any of these new restrictions... <'TK>< .. To much federal control !! ... I think Alpha hit it dead on !!! :(

Alphahawk 12-13-2012 12:17 AM

In doing some research on this I came across this article. http://www.yankton.net/articles/2012...6589513365.txt

I tell you guys not only our politicians not able to do any constructive work...but they are allowing rules and regulations to be made that serve no purpose other than control. This is really disturbing.


Regards

jad2t 12-13-2012 12:23 AM

I'm absolutely disgusted by this. I planned to spend a lot of time bank fishing the OHD generation starting next week now that the semester as ended. As rough of a semester as it was, I was really looking forward to enjoying what I enjoy most. Apparently starting tomorrow we will no longer be allowed.

Merv brings up a great point. I will be outraged at the TWRA if they decide to start ticketing people for fishing below the dams meanwhile ignoring any report they get of illegal immigrants keeping everything in their cast nets. IF they support our opinion on this, as they say they do, they should just "not notice" me fishing below the dam next week.

MNfisher 12-13-2012 06:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jad2t (Post 27446)
I'm absolutely disgusted by this. I planned to spend a lot of time bank fishing the OHD generation starting next week now that the semester as ended. As rough of a semester as it was, I was really looking forward to enjoying what I enjoy most. Apparently starting tomorrow we will no longer be allowed.

Merv brings up a great point. I will be outraged at the TWRA if they decide to start ticketing people for fishing below the dams meanwhile ignoring any report they get of illegal immigrants keeping everything in their cast nets. IF they support our opinion on this, as they say they do, they should just "not notice" me fishing below the dam next week.

I don't believe that anywhere did it mention about any bank fishing access. And if you read the article that Alpha posted about Yankton, SD. They closed the area off to boats and not bank fisherman. I am very certain that any closure will be only including boats. Which I still feel is ridiculous. I guess we will find out today.

CreekWalker 12-13-2012 10:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jad2t (Post 27446)
I'm absolutely disgusted by this. I planned to spend a lot of time bank fishing the OHD generation starting next week now that the semester as ended. As rough of a semester as it was, I was really looking forward to enjoying what I enjoy most. Apparently starting tomorrow we will no longer be allowed.

Merv brings up a great point. I will be outraged at the TWRA if they decide to start ticketing people for fishing below the dams meanwhile ignoring any report they get of illegal immigrants keeping everything in their cast nets. IF they support our opinion on this, as they say they do, they should just "not notice" me fishing below the dam next week.

If you are going to try to beat up the gub'ment know that they are restricting boats not bank fisherman.

I believe that agelsssone said "illegal fisherman" not "illegal immigrants". Not to speak for him but perhaps he was referring to illegal activities such as exceeding bag limits via cast nets (among other tactics, presumably).

browntrout 12-13-2012 10:40 AM

Here it is!!!!
 
NASHVILLE, Tenn. – The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Nashville District is finalizing plans to implement 24/7 restricted waterborne access to hazardous waters immediately upstream and downstream of all Corps-owned locks and dams, flood control dams and multipurpose dams on the Cumberland River and its adjoining tributaries. This action moves the Nashville District into full compliance with Corps regulations.

Public information meetings are planned for Paducah, Ky., Nashville, Tenn., Cookeville, Tenn. and Somerset, Ky. in January 2013. These meetings will allow the public to respond to the proposed implementation plans. Detailed information for each meeting’s time and location will be provided to the public as soon as they are finalized.

The restricted areas will be the minimum area allowed per Corps regulations upstream and downstream of locks, dams, and power plant facilities. All forms of water access within the restricted areas will be prohibited including boating, swimming and wading. The Corps continues to allow bank fishing in all areas that were previously approved, including areas adjacent to some restricted areas. The restricted areas will be small areas compared to the entire tailwater below the dams on federal property. Fishing and boating will still be allowed in these non-restricted areas.

“We understand the tightened restricted areas in the Nashville District may be unpopular, but it is necessary for the district to enforce a more restrictive policy that complies more effectively with U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’ ER 1130-2-520, Chapter 10,” said Freddie Bell, chief of the Natural Resource Management Branch. “The increased restriction will also provide the highest level of public safety and address physical security issues.”

Since 2009, three fatalities, one serious injury and 10 near misses/rescues have occurred in the hazardous waters immediately downstream of dams on the Cumberland River and its adjoining tributaries. Life jacket wear has been ineffective in these areas, since all of the victims who drowned were wearing a life jacket.

The immediate hazardous water areas above and below dams in the Nashville District are best described as industrial areas that pose a high level of risk for the public because of the hydroelectric, spilling, sluicing and lock operations that are often present or begin with little or no notice. Such water releases can change a dry riverbed or calm waters into a life-threatening situation within seconds that can swamp, capsize and trap boats and people in turbulent waters.

“We want the public to understand safety is the Agency’s highest priority,” said Bell. “The tailwater directly below a dam is a high risk area and fishing in this area is a high risk activity. As we comply with Corps regulations by restricting these areas, we are also keeping the public safe.”

For more information, on the “Restricted Areas Around Dams” please go to http://www.lrn.usace.army.mil/pao/ne..._near_dams.htm.

The public can obtain news, updates and information from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Nashville District on the district’s website at www.lrn.usace.army.mil, on Facebook at http://www.facebook.com/nashvillecorps and on Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/nashvillecorps.



Read more: http://www.dvidshub.net/news/99240/n...#ixzz2Ewm2jmEZ

Travis C. 12-13-2012 10:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jad2t (Post 27446)
Merv brings up a great point. I will be outraged at the TWRA if they decide to start ticketing people for fishing below the dams meanwhile ignoring any report they get of illegal immigrants keeping everything in their cast nets. IF they support our opinion on this, as they say they do, they should just "not notice" me fishing below the dam next week.

Best I remember from the last TWRC (the commission that approves the TWRA regs/laws) they voted to not enforce and stay out of the upcoming Corps changes leaving it up to them to police.

browntrout 12-13-2012 10:43 AM

THey also posted this link:
http://www.lrn.usace.army.mil/pao/ne..._near_dams.htm

If you look at the picture close you might recognize that person. I wont say who it is I will let him identify himself if he wishes.

Roy

Travis C. 12-13-2012 10:56 AM

Some of these areas are wading friendly or not very deep on low water. If it was such a safety concer then why can't the "zone" be in effect when the facility is operating and when its not be open?

In reality none are dangerous if its not running.

Jim 12-13-2012 10:56 AM

All of the site restricted areas are on the website also.

Here is Old Hickory;

http://www.lrn.usace.army.mil/pao/Bo...-CE999-009.jpg

And Center Hill (Caney Fork River)

http://www.lrn.usace.army.mil/pao/Bo...-CE999-002.jpg

Really bummer at Old Hickory.

Jim

jad2t 12-13-2012 11:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CreekWalker (Post 27451)
If you are going to try to beat up the gub'ment know that they are restricting boats not bank fisherman.

I believe that agelsssone said "illegal fisherman" not "illegal immigrants". Not to speak for him but perhaps he was referring to illegal activities such as exceeding bag limits via cast nets (among other tactics, presumably).

Many times those two terms are synonymous so I may have gotten ahead of myself due to what I personally have witnessed over the years but we won't go there...

As far as only restricting boaters, that makes their argument of our "safety" even more ridiculous. Are bank fishermen not at risk if they act foolishly during generation? Sure they are. You can't pass laws to eliminate stupid. They even said in the article Roy posted that since 2009 there have been 3 deaths, 1 serious injury, and 10 near misses. While each event is tragic and I hate to hear someone died or was injured, those numbers aren't that staggering. It's not like someone was dying every week from fishing below a dam. Those numbers are not even remotely serious enough to justify a measure like this.

Jim 12-13-2012 11:04 AM

Here is a strange fact. The policy that they are getting in line with was established on November 29, 1996. If it was so important, do you think it may have been dealt within the past 16 years?

Jim

Travis C. 12-13-2012 11:10 AM

From their Q&A portion on the link:

Q16. We have a number of petition signatures against these restrictions. Will the Corps change its decision based on public opposition?

Answer: No, regulatory guidance requires us to establish restricted areas for the hazardous waters around dams. The Corps understands this change in policy may be unpopular for some visitors but public safety is paramount regarding all project operations.

spottedbass 12-13-2012 11:13 AM

The restriction above Old Hickory really stinks. That was a great bank for catching smallmouth and spotted bass.

No more fishing the "pond" or the water fall at Center Hill.

Alphahawk 12-13-2012 11:19 AM

It sucks all the way around. Strange how the two videos posted on their site about incidents are private videos...you can't view them...LOL. I can't imagine never fishing the pond again at Center Hill. Of course the Army has never used logic. The percentage of lake deaths is almost 100 times the deaths below dams. It is going to be incumbent on us to become activist and do as Americans have done for 200 years when things get outrageous...take it to the streets...in this case take it to the dams. I am sure we can get literally a thousand boaters...kayakers...to show up below Old Hickory.....in the Pond on the Caney. This will come down to a battle of will between us and the Army. I think in mass this is something we can cause a lot of discomfort for politicians if we stick together and have the will to see it through. All people need to understand that this is just not about us fishing where we want...this one step could lead to many stupid regs and rules that would impact everyones life....livelihood....in some fashion. It is time to say enough is enough.




Regards

tkwalker 12-13-2012 11:39 AM

From a very reliable source !! <'TK><
 
""Thanks for keeping me updated. This guy is not going away. Please tell your readers that TW RA is not going to enforce this law. Will be totally up to the Corps of Engineers. This commander has been told that By the director."

browntrout 12-13-2012 11:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alphahawk (Post 27464)
It sucks all the way around. Strange how the two videos posted on their site about incidents are private videos...you can't view them...LOL. I can't imagine never fishing the pond again at Center Hill. Of course the Army has never used logic. The percentage of lake deaths is almost 100 times the deaths below dams. It is going to be incumbent on us to become activist and do as Americans have done for 200 years when things get outrageous...take it to the streets...in this case take it to the dams. I am sure we can get literally a thousand boaters...kayakers...to show up below Old Hickory.....in the Pond on the Caney. This will come down to a battle of will between us and the Army. I think in mass this is something we can cause a lot of discomfort for politicians if we stick together and have the will to see it through. All people need to understand that this is just not about us fishing where we want...this one step could lead to many stupid regs and rules that would impact everyones life....livelihood....in some fashion. It is time to say enough is enough.


I have a black riverhawk ready to go. Lets just set a date!!!

Roy



Regards


Alphahawk 12-13-2012 11:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tkwalker (Post 27465)
""Thanks for keeping me updated. This guy is not going away. Please tell your readers that TW RA is not going to enforce this law. Will be totally up to the Corps of Engineers. This commander has been told that By the director."

tk....how many guides wil be impacted at Cordell Hull that guide for Stripers...or other species...will be affected by this? I am assuming we are talking about a lot of lost revenue for them...not to mention local hotels...restaurants and so on.


Regards


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:13 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.